Net (2-channel) people corner national newspaper to near death in Japan

Mainichi newspaper is considered as one of the major national newspapers in Japan, along with Nikkei, Asahi, Yomiuri and Sankei.  Yet, it is now at the verge of breakdown by people on the Net, particularly on notorious "2 channel" (anonimous bulletin board).

This article is based on the summary of events on Gigazine site.  Thank you, Gigazine-san.

It all started from series of articles on Mainichi's English site column, "Mainichi Daily News - WaiWai".  It is supposed to be a small and soft column to introduce Japanese everyday life and culture, but its editor Ryann Conell has gone too far and too soft.  He picked quite obscene and unreliable news in Japanese version of tabloids and wrote articles based on them.  As a woman, I hesitate to introduce what he wrote, and now the original site is gone, but I just say that they are so disgusting and unpermittably obscene.  Conell says he kept writing because he considers it as a separate part from the main Mainichi newspaper and he claims on his column that it is a mere translation and Mainichi does not bear responsiblity on its varidity.

The problem is that people do not read such disclaimers.  Japanese readers would understand that it is a total nonsense by looking at sources, but from the eyes of English speakers who don't know Japan very well, it is a part of a Japanese national newspaper and one of the small amount of English information about Japan.  It can be very misleading for them.  It could get away if it is a part of the original stupid tabloids or Conell's personal blog, but since it is a part of mainichi.co.jp domain, it is clearly unescapable.

According to Gigazine, the column had been going on for several years, despite some internal warnings.  Finally some concerned Japanese readers started to send complaints to Mainichi since last year.  But alas, Mainichi somehow ignored them.

In April 2008, people over at 2 channel picked it up, and started rallying that Mainichi is internationally spreading an inaccurate and shameful information about Japan.  On June 25, Mainichi apologized about the column, but shortly after, they announced that they would sue the people (on 2 channel) who incorrectly blame their staff on the Net.  That announcement added fuel in the fire.

2 channel people received it as the war declaration from Mainichi, and they fired the most deadly final weapon; claim e-mails to the companies who advertise on Mainichi on-line versions.

That was totally effective, and by mid-July, ads by major corporations such as Nissan, Kirin (beer), JCB (credit card) and Fujitsu disappeared from Mainichi site.  As of today, Mainichi.co.jp main page only carries Mainichi's own advertisements - just to fill the space.

On July 20, Mainichi raised the white flag.  They shut down Mainichi Daily News site, and again, officially apologized, with their own explanation of what happened.  Now, all you can see on former Mainichi Daily page is their apology statement.

But net people still don't accept their apology.  They cite that July 20 is the middle day of 3-day weekend, and that their apology is not serious enough.

On the bottom of such resentment, a deep distrust of net people against Mainichi and other mass media has been percolating for a long time.  They believe that Japanese mass media enjoy accusing people or companies who make mistakes, and often times, they even take up trivial things and extend it to extreme, until the accused companies go out of business.  In recent cases, for example, Senba Kiccho, Osaka's high-class restaurant, went out of business due to a scandal that they re-used left over food, and the media's hype against it was rather out-of-scale.  Mainichi, among newspapers, and TBS, among TV stations, are often the major target of Net people's resentment.

And among the executives of these media companies, there is also a deep distrust against the Internet at large, and particularly to 2 channel.  They despise the Internet, and Gigazine people believe that Mainichi executives probably rank "online version" of Mainichi as the secondary and did not pay attention, and it was one element that caused such a mess.

Net people do not have any central figure to negotiate with.  And they probably will not forgive Mainichi until Mainichi go bankrupt, given the background of their resentment.  Other traditional media also are quiet about this incident, because they do not want to get catch the fire either.

The Shosteck Group becomes a strategic partner

The Shosteck Group, a boutique consulting firm specialized in mobile telecommunication, has become ENOTECH's strategic partner.

Jane Zweig, Chair and CEO of The Shosteck Group, has been known as the top intelligence in the world's mobile industry.  She was recently featured in CBS Market Watch, as she has often predicted what would actually happen in the new technology or service, contrary to the hype of the time.   She has particularly deep understanding of the mobile handset behavior, thus she looks at the industry from the handset/user point-of-view, rather than the provider/infra perspetive.

We have worked together on project-by-project basis in the past, and are currently working to create more value in the industry, by matching her US/Europe industry knowledge/human network and mine in US/Japan.

Stay tuned!!

Why US mobile contents business is STILL not successful

I am at CTIA - the mobile phone conference - in Las Vegas, and on Monday, there was a pre-show event called "Mobile Entertainment Live". I have been involved in the mobile contents industry for the past several years, and am quite disappointed that people are still complaining about the same things.

There was even a panel designed to "complain" all the problems that the contents providers face, repeating their same mantra to blame phone carriers, rights holders (such as music labels and movie studios) and everybody else.

In my eyes, though, they are missing an important point - "women". 

I recently talked to a guy from RockYou, one of the top Facebook application providers, and he mentioned that their CEO reads teen girl's magazines to come up with new ideas, because they have the biggest "viral" power to spread their application. Sure enough, Web2.0 community understands it. So they are successful.

Even in Japan, the land of male-centric society, mobile contents industry has plethora of female entrepreneurs, most notably Tomoko Namba of DeNA (provider of ad-supported game/SNS service Mobaga Town) and Yoshimi Ogawa of Index (the pioneer of i-mode contents). And their main customers also are young women. They love to communicate, have fun together, and listen to their friends. Great customers for mobile contents.

Here at CTIA, in the US, the land of the free and where women are supposed to be better situated in business than their across-the-pacific neighbor, the place is just full of men. Women are often ignored both as providers and as customers, even in "that" mobile contents segment. They talk about sports, hip-hop and shooting games - so much focusing on 18-and-older male audience.

5 years, and nothing has changed. You guys just don't understand your potential customers. And that is the formula for failure. Stop complaining and do something about it.

On Vox: MOMOYA TVCM archive - "public domain" video effort in Japan

The first major public domain video-sharing project in Japan, by Research Institute of Digital Media and Contents, Keoi University (Keio DMC), in collaboration with Kawasaki City Museum, is now open to public.

The site, "History of Showa, reflected upon Japanese dinner table", is a neat collection from the long-standing animated commercial series by a processed food company Momoya, broadcasted on television between 1953 and 1993.  The main character, a big-nose guy with round glasses, is Norihei Miki, one of the great comedians in Showa era.  Momoya contributed its entire CM video archive, 218 pieces in total, to Kawasaki City Museum to be used for the purpose of study and education.  Half of the collection have already made available on Keio DMC's own video sharing platform "Volume One" since last October on trial basis, and at this time, the team has selected 20 of them that show the historical background of the time it was broadcasted, with explanation of these backgrounds both in Japanese and English.  For foreign visitors, the site has a separate page to explain the food items in subject, as well as some of Japanese-specific CM characters that Norihei inpersonates, such as Sumo wrestler and ninja.

The project is significant, not only because it is the first case of comprehensive collection of TV CM video in Japan, but also because it is open to public for free, for academic purposes.  In Japan, the video copyrights holders has much stronger control than in the U.S., and the debate over the legitimacy of video sharing on the Internet has much harsher tone against free sharing.

The project leader and my long-term friend, Junko Iwabuchi of Keio DMC, says she wants to make it an example of the public domain effort on the net, and let people know that the museum contents can be shared with much ease and low cost through the net.

Please visit:
http://www.documentshowa.jp/

(You need the latest version of Flash Player.)

Anyway, the videos are quite fun to watch, and you can see the early days of Japanese animation.  Enjoy!!

Originally posted on enotech.vox.com

On Vox: Blackout in Silicon Valley

We were out in Mexico for a few days for New Years Vacation, and came back to find out that we had a blackout in our house.

It turned out that our area was the hardest hit in the area, and as of now, which is supposedly after more than 30 hours after the blackout tarted, the power still is not back on.

We have the backup circuits and UPS and everything, but nothing is of use.  The Net is out, and I cannot do any work done.  I don't have any radio anymore, other than Pandora, and of course it does not work.  I cannot charge the cell phone. 

It is such an irony.  The only way savior is the car.  I can recharge my cell battery, run to our friend's house who has the power to connect to the net.  The car has the heat and light.  As long as the car runs, I am OK.

I have stock up with canned soup and instant ramen, firewood and battery to survive for one more night without power.  Hope it will come back on tomorrow.

Originally posted on enotech.vox.com

Japan's WiMax - another Galapagos?

Japan's industry people often criticize their own mobile industry "Galapagos".  The largest carrier NTT DoCoMo chose their proprietary technology for 2G, and therefore became segregated from the rest of the world and the market developed in quite unique way, just like unique animals in Galapagos.

It turned out to be an obvious bad decision, so they have tried very hard to standardize their technology in 3G cellular.  Yet, in 2.5GHz wireless broadband spectrum, they have made another "Galapagotizing" decision.

Yesterday, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communication (MIC) decided to give 2.5GHz licenses to two groups, one headed by KDDI, utilizing WiMax, and another by WillCom with "Advanced PHS" technology.

In the 90's, NTT tried and failed to make PHS their home-grown technology to be used worldwide.  It did make it to China and some other Asian countries as the cheap fixed wireless alternative, yet it is of very limited use compared to mobile phones.

PHS mostly failed, except for a so-so success by Willcom, with its data plan for PC card modem.  So Willcom does have some expressed interest from its customers for the higher speed connection, but in the larger state of spectrum politics, it looks nothing but another try for Japan's home-grown technology again, with another risk of "Galapagotization".

Even KDDI's WiMax, whose consortium includes Intel - the largest backer of WiMax -, with the growing clouds over mobile WiMax initiative in the United States, may not be the sure bet.  It is a shame to see Japan going further into the Galapagotization, just because it is too advanced and technology decision has to be made much earlier than the rest of the world.

I know that everyone wants to escape from Qualcomm's reign in CDMA monopoly world.  Yes, I know it is politics.  But I am still a bit concerned.

Originally posted on enotech.vox.com

This is SO STUPID and FUNNY!!

I had a hard time hanging onto my chair reading this Japanese discussion board 2channel last night...

Earlier this week a Labour MP called for the Union flag to be redesigned to include the Welsh Dragon.

Then the Japanese 2-channeler came up with this.                        

   
       
                
                        3848cef9                     

            

               

            

           

   

and MORE!!

2-channel creative Union Jack + Wales Flag

And OMG... UK's top newspaper

Telegraph Dec. 1  Japan offers to solve "Union Jack Problem"

There are MUCH FUNNIER ONE on the original thread than the ones picked up by Telegraph.

And I am SURE that the country who invented MONTY PYSON don't take this up as a POLITICAL issue!!  (Funny that many 2-channel participants are SERIOUSLY worried about it!)

 

Originally posted on enotech.vox.com

My memo

Just learned these numbers.  I am writing them down for my own memo, but interesting numbers...

1.  Mobile handset share in Japan

Sharp  19.6%  (up 4.4 points)
Panasonic  13.2%  (down 2.9 points)
NEC  13.2%  (down 2.4 points)

Background:  Sharp was successful in their new "One-seg" phone from Softbank  905SH, with a rotatable screen.  They named its mobile phones as "Aquos Keitai" to coincide with their LED TV sets, to emphasize their high-quality LED screens.  They have 43.9% market share on LED TV as well.  LED share is as follows:

Sharp  43.9%
Sony  18.0%
Panasonic  17.0%

Source:  Nohon Keizai Shimbun

2.  Mixi growth stops on the Web, continues on Mobile

http://www.itmedia.co.jp/news/articles/0707/31/news089.html
http://www.itmedia.co.jp/news/articles/0707/31/news069.html

Mixi has just exceeded 10mil. member number in May, but their page view on PC web is on decline, while its mobile PV is increasing.  (below numbers from June 07)

PC web:  6.38bil. total (-7%), 607.0 per member (-19%)
Mobile:  5.27bil. total (+30%), 493.3 per member (+13%)

Accordingly, CEO Kenji Kasahara states that they are planning to introduce "Mobagei" type casual game and avatar functions, and opening its doors to minors (currently 18+ only).

Source:  IT Media

Rationing economy of mobile - deep division between web world and mobile

TuucyoI was at a speech event held by DoCoMo Labs USA in Palo Alto earlier today.  There, Jimmy Wales of Wikipedia, Jonathan Zittrain of Oxford University and Peter Hirshberg of Technorati talked about their insights about Net and Web, and the whole thing was quite enlightening and exciting for me.

Once they started their panel discussion among them, however, trying to address some implications to mobile communication for the organizer, it started boring me.  Their discussion went into the same old accusation that mobile carriers are evil who try to control their closed universe, which I have been hearing in numerous occasions in the mobile world.  While they do have a point and the mobile network has started to open a little bit, I don't think such accusations will work to open the mobile network.

In my younger days back in Japan, there was a thing called "rice purchase certificate".  It is hard to believe now, but 50 years ago, Japan was a poor country and had to ration its staple food, namely rice, and my parents had to show this certificate at a store to buy rice.  Amazingly, the system remained active until 1981, according to Japanese Wikipedia.

Mobile network, by laws of physics, is a rationing economy.  There is a limited bandwidth of radiowave, and the technology still has certain limits of number of users within that bandwidth.  There is a very limited supply of data bandwidth to start with.

People also find more value in mobility and voice quality than the bandwith, unfortunately, for cell phones.  Even if you can use quasi-DSL speed with your 3G phone, if the simple voice coverage area is limited, very few people would buy it.  Coverage area, which is supplied by carriers' towers, is still limited to more populated areas and wherever the zoning is somewhat favorable (which often contradict each other).  Landline broadband doesn't have to deal with this matter.

Jimbo Wales said, with more competition, a more open carrier will win over incumbent closed carriers, but that is not the reality.  T-mobile and Sprint are generally more "open" to a certain degree, but people still buy AT&T and Verizon because they have better coverage.  Because Verizon has lots of customers particularly in crowded cities, they always have to be careful not to deteriorate their voice quality, and as a result, they have to ration their bandwith very carefully.  As a result, the more closed carrier have better voice quality and they actually win more customers.  It works totally different way, at least for now.  And if the service is based on this rationing economy, carriers have to be in strong control.  It is sellers' market, where demand exceeds supply.

Some day in the future, maybe a revolutionary technology will be developed to free us from this laws of physics somehow.  Until that time, we have to live with this rationing economy.  PC-based web culture people often don't understand this reality.

Apple agitates against Japanese government - or did it?

ApplerumorA couple of weeks ago, Japanese blogosphere boiled up with the unusually harsh comment that Apple Japan inc. made on the issue of "personal recording tax" and copyrights policy in general to Agency of Cultural Affairs, a part of Japanese government, basically telling them to "go to hxxx".

The comment attacks this tax applied to digital recording devices sold in Japan to compensate for possible damages done by users recording and copying contents illegally since 1992.  It is not applied to iPod, but is currently discussed to be applied and naturally Apple is firmly opposing it, and attacking the rights holder organizations who are pushing it.  That part is quite understandable, but the point here is that the tone of the comment is unheard of in official documents in Japan.

It goes like "the criticism against the digital devices (as the source of all the bad things) is totally groundless," "the rights holder organizations are self-contradicting and arrogant," then go on to say "the Agency knowingly appointed two scholars in the personal recording issue committee who wrongly claim that other major countries have similar tax and those (with specific names) who appointed them should not escape the responsibility".  And at the end, they dare to say "Agency of Cultural Affairs has shut out Apple from the committees and deciding thing in absent trial ... Agency is closed minded and not capable of managing the copyrights issues, therefore we strongly hope that the issue will be transferred to another governmental agency."

Since it was known on the Net on June 2, as you might expect, Japanese bloggers hailed this Apple statement, and added zillions of even harsher comments against the Agency and JASRAC, Japanese version of RIAA.

However, the tone in the original Japanese document is so agitating that many people started to doubt if it really came from Apple Inc., a major corporation in the world and certainly in Japan as well.  The document itself is on Prime Minister's Office webpage and is definitely legit, but Engadget Japan puts up some questionable points on June 7.

It says that the Agency received this comment from someone who claims to be from Apple Japan, but they did not take any further confirmation action, and that Apple has not made any official statement whether it is truly from Apple or not.

As of today, I have not read any follow up info, and the source of the agitating comment is still a mystery.

Did Apple actually did this, or was this the act of a ninja, again??